Roles and Responsibilities (R&R): The Hiring Costs of Temporary Employees vs. Contractors vs. Consultants
Steven Moore
Good day readers. We continue our mini-series of articles that focuses on some of the different types of professionals that businesses work with. These workers are types of contingent professionals: temporary employees, contractors, and consultants.
In this article, we will evaluate the hiring costs a business must consider for each of these professional types. We look at the financial impact on a business from hiring each professional type.
Check out our lead article in this series here where we discuss each type of role in greater depth.
Â
The Hiring Costs of Contingent Professionals
When comparing the hiring costs of temporary employees, contractors, and consultants, several factors come into play, including recruitment, compensation, benefits, and overhead costs. These costs and factors for each contingent professional type include:
Temporary Employees
Recruitment Costs: Hiring temporary employees often involves using a staffing agency, which can charge a placement fee. This fee is usually a percentage of the temporary employee's hourly wage. Alternatively, if a company hires temps directly, the recruitment costs might include advertising, interviewing, and administrative expenses, though these are generally lower for temp roles than for permanent positions.
Wages: Temporary employees typically earn lower hourly wages compared to contractors and consultants. The company pays these wages directly or through the staffing agency.
Benefits and Payroll Costs: Temporary employees generally do not receive benefits like health insurance, retirement contributions, or paid leave from the employer. However, the company still bears some payroll costs, such as unemployment insurance, workers’ compensation, and employer contributions to Social Security and Medicare.
Overhead Costs: There may be additional costs for onboarding, training, and providing the necessary tools or workspace for temporary employees, though these are usually minimal compared to full-time employees.
Â
Contractors
Recruitment Costs: Contractors can be found through specialized job boards, agencies, or directly via networking. Recruitment costs can vary, especially if hiring through an agency, which may charge a fee. Direct recruitment might involve advertising costs and time spent on vetting candidates.
Compensation: Contractors are typically paid higher hourly or project-based rates than temporary employees due to their specialized skills and the independent nature of their work. These rates are agreed upon upfront and can be quite variable depending on the project's complexity and the contractor's expertise.
No Benefits: Contractors do not receive employee benefits, which can make them more cost-effective in some scenarios despite their higher rates. The lack of benefit costs saves the company money compared to hiring a full-time employee.
Overhead Costs: Contractors often work off-site or use their own equipment, which can reduce overhead costs for the company. However, if the contractor needs specific tools or software provided by the company, this could add to the cost.
Â
Consultants
Recruitment Costs: Hiring consultants can be more costly, especially if engaging with a consulting firm. The recruitment process might involve retaining a consultancy or engaging with a specialized recruiting firm. This could include a retainer fee or a placement fee if using a firm to find independent consultants.
Consulting Fees: Consultants generally command the highest rates due to their expertise and the strategic nature of their work. They may charge hourly, by project, or on a retainer basis. These fees can be substantial, reflecting the consultant’s experience and the value they bring.
No Benefits: Like contractors, consultants do not receive benefits, which means the company saves on these costs. However, the higher fees they command can offset these savings.
Overhead Costs: Consultants typically work independently and do not require workspace, equipment, or other resources from the company. However, if they are brought on-site or need access to proprietary tools, there could be additional costs involved.
Â
Overall Cost Considerations
Temporary Employees: Generally the least expensive in terms of hiring and compensation. While there might be staffing agency fees and minimal overhead costs, the absence of benefits and lower hourly wages make them a cost-effective option for short-term, low-skill tasks.
Contractors: More expensive than temporary employees due to higher hourly/project rates, but with the advantage of no benefit costs. Contractors are a good value when specialized skills are needed for a specific task or project.
Consultants: The most expensive option in terms of upfront costs due to their high fees. However, they provide significant value through expert advice and strategic guidance. The cost is justified when the outcome can have a substantial impact on the company’s performance or direction.
Â
Bringing it all together
The choice between temporary employees, contractors, and consultants depends on the specific needs of the business, the level of expertise required, and the budget available for the role. A summarized hiring cost breakdown for each contingent professional type looks like this:
Temporary Employees: Lowest hiring costs, ideal for short-term needs with routine tasks.
Contractors: Moderate hiring costs, suitable for specialized, project-based work without long-term commitment.
Consultants: Highest hiring costs, best for strategic guidance and complex problem-solving where expert input is crucial.
As businesses navigate the best solution for their operational needs, the choice between temporary employees, contractors, and consultants requires serious thought and planning. Ultimately, it's important to note that the choice between either one or all of these solutions depends on the specific needs, size, and complexity of the organization, as well as budget considerations.